Guides / Origins

What Is Specialty Coffee?

Specialty coffee is a grade of coffee. In the industry's standard definition, it means a coffee that scores 80 points or more on a 100-point scale, tasted by a trained and certified taster. This guide explains how that grade works, what else a coffee must pass, and why the definition is now being debated.

The short definition

According to Perfect Daily Grind, which cites the Coffee Quality Institute and the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA), coffee is specialty when a certified taster, such as a Q grader, scores it 80 or above on the SCA's 100-point scale. Coffee that scores below 80 is classed as commodity grade.

The score bands

Both Perfect Daily Grind articles below give the same bands:

Score Grade
90 to 100 Outstanding
85 to 89.99 Excellent
80 to 84.99 Very good
Below 80 Not specialty (commodity grade)

So 80 is the entry point, not the top. A coffee that scores 82 and one that scores 92 are both specialty, but they sit in different bands.

It is also a physical check

The score comes from tasting, but green (unroasted) coffee must also pass an inspection. Two Perfect Daily Grind articles describe the rules slightly differently:

Perfect Daily Grind, 2020 (citing the SCA's physical requirements) Perfect Daily Grind, 2024
Sample size 300 g of coffee 350 g of green coffee
Defects allowed No more than five full defects, and no primary defects No more than five defects

The 2020 article adds more physical requirements: a maximum of 5% of beans above or below the stated screen size, at least one distinctive attribute (body, flavor, aroma or acidity), no faults or taints, no quakers, and 9 to 13% moisture.

Because the two articles give different sample sizes, treat the exact numbers as "about 300 to 350 g, about five defects" and check the SCA's current protocol if you need the precise figure.

How tasting works

Scoring is done by cupping: a trained taster smells and tastes samples side by side under a set protocol. Coffee Review, which rates coffees separately, explains that its own tastings are blind, with coffees identified only by number, and that it uses the SCAA cupping protocol for coffees meant for brewing.

Coffee Review's 100-point scale is its own, not the SCA's grading line. Its guide describes 85 to 86 as acceptable and solid but nothing exceptional, 89 to 90 as very good and drinkable, and 93 to 94 as exceptional with no significant negatives. In a typical tasting report it tests 40 to 100 specialty coffees and publishes about ten reviews, which almost always score 90 or higher.

Does under 80 mean bad?

No, according to the people Perfect Daily Grind spoke to in 2024. A former roastery worker and SCA-authorized trainer said her team bought coffees under 80 points, and that missing the threshold does not make a coffee bad or inferior. A roaster co-founder said specialty is a grade of coffee and should not decide who is allowed to drink it. The score is a quality marker for the lot, not a verdict on every cup.

Why the definition is being debated

Perfect Daily Grind's 2020 article describes "specialty" shifting from a measured grade toward an ideal tied to transparency, traceability, direct trade and sustainability. It warns that the two meanings can diverge, and that the word is often used loosely as marketing language. It also reports concern that raising the bar to 85 would unfairly exclude producers of 80 to 84.99 coffees.

The SCA itself is changing the system. Daily Coffee News reported in April 2023 that:

  • The SCA proposed a new definition of specialty coffee in 2021, the first to raise extrinsic value, such as a coffee's perceived value in the marketplace, as a possible defining attribute.
  • The SCA's cupping form and protocol had not been significantly revised since 2004, and the form gives a single 100-point score.
  • The SCA launched a beta of its Coffee Value Assessment, designed to replace the cupping form eventually. It separates an objective description of a coffee's flavor from the taster's impression of quality, and it also covers physical and extrinsic assessments.

Perfect Daily Grind's January 2024 article says the 100-point scale is still what most industry professionals use to define specialty coffee.

What this means when you buy coffee

  • "Specialty" has a precise, checkable meaning only when a score or grade comes with it.
  • The word alone does not tell you the score, the roast date or the origin.
  • Single-origin and blended coffees can both be specialty. Our guide to what single-origin coffee means covers that choice.
  • For where coffee grows and how origin shapes the cup, see our coffee origins guide.

FAQ

What is specialty coffee?

Coffee that scores 80 or above on the SCA's 100-point scale, tasted by a certified grader, and that passes a physical inspection for defects.

What score makes coffee specialty?

80 points. From there, 80 to 84.99 is "very good," 85 to 89.99 is "excellent," and 90 to 100 is "outstanding."

Is a coffee under 80 points bad?

Not necessarily. Industry professionals interviewed by Perfect Daily Grind said coffees below 80 can be good, and some roasters buy them.

Does Coffee Review use the same scale?

It uses its own 100-point ratings, with blind tastings and the SCAA cupping protocol for brewing coffees. Its scale and the SCA's grading line are separate things.

Is the definition changing?

Yes. The SCA proposed a new definition in 2021 and has launched a Coffee Value Assessment meant to replace its cupping form over time.

From our shop

Want to taste it?

Our coffees are single-origin or blended, roasted medium, and available in 7 grind options: Whole bean, Drip, Pour over, French press, Cold brew, Espresso and Moka pot. If you want to start with a Yemeni cup, try Cloud Terrace, with grapefruit zest, juicy fruit and a sweet nougat finish. Browse all our coffees.

Shop all coffees

More guides

All guides →